
So, the problem isn’t the quality of songs. Some of them – ‘I Fought In A War’, ‘The Model’, ‘The Wrong Girl’ – are excellent, but they need an extra sparkle. ‘Dear Catastrophe Waitress’, their next proper album would contain that sparkle, matching the ambition of this album to a producer who could handle it. It would have been great to know what Trevor Horn could have done with a track like the closing ‘There’s Too Much Love’ – a track which has a good song buried within it, but which sounds slightly messy all in all.
However, fans of Belle and Sebastian should find enough in this album to make it a worthwhile listen. Only ‘The Chalet Lines’ really doesn’t work. Perhaps it’s possible to place a song about rape onto a light hearted pop album without sounding horribly crass, but not on this evidence.
No comments:
Post a Comment