
Beach Boys albums tend to be a bit of a mixed bag. With the exception of an obvious select few, each album tends to contain some great stuff, some mediocre stuff, and some rubbish – sometimes all within the same track. ‘Carl & The Passions’ is no different, but it’s a fascinating album.
Following the meltdown of Brian Wilson, the band was forced to adapt to survive. The post Pet Sounds years saw a variety of line up alterations and stylistics adaptations. By the time of this album, nominal control of the band had fallen to Carl, the youngest of the Wilson brothers. As you might expect, therefore, this album is somewhat dominated by him as both a producer and, to a lesser extent, a vocalist. In actual fact, he only takes full lead vocal duties for two of the eight songs, but they’re an important two: the opening track ‘You Need A Mess of Help To Stand Alone’ and ‘Marcella’, the central track, and widely regarded highlight of the album. These two tracks also represent the main writing contributions from Brian, proving that even in his wrecked state, he still had some talent.
Carl’s other major contribution to the album, and the band at the time, was the recruitment of two new members to cover Dennis Wilson’s drumming duties whilst he recovered from injury, and generally beef up the band. Happily, this also helped to cover for Bruce Johnston who left early in the recordings (though he would return a few albums later). Blondie Chaplin and Ricky Fataar are a re-invigorating presence in the band both as musicians and songwriters. Allowing them to write, produce and sing two songs virtually independently could be seen as either brave or desperate, depending on how charitable you might be feeling. Either way, it was an interesting move. Their two songs, ‘Hold On Dear Brother’ and ‘Here She Comes’ are excellent – really very good indeed – but they sound and feel very removed from the rest of the album. Almost as incongruous are the contributions from Dennis. ‘Make It Good’ and ‘Cuddle Up’ showcase his fragile if evocative voice over a bed of strings and piano, and display the fact that his own talent’s were developing well, if in a different direction to the band as a whole. The remaining two tracks, ‘He Come Down’ and ‘All This Is That’ are the token efforts from Mike Love and Al Jardine who wrote them together with input from Brian and Carl respectively. The first achieves a reasonably successful faux-gospel sound, though it’s lyrics – another feeble attempt to spread the joys of Transcendental Meditation – are somewhat grating. ‘All This Is That’ is better, thanks to its more subtle approach, and a rather lovely vocal blend.
Listened to in one approach, it’s hard to fathom any kind of direction from this album. The different members of the band all appear to be aiming for completely different styles and goals which makes this album function a little like ‘The White Album’ (although less ambitious and frankly, less good). However, there is a lot to enjoy here as long as you’re not expecting any kind of consistency, and the band, with the same line up, would achieve something a little more harmonious with their next album. Worth a listen.